People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Was back in town for work from Florida for one day, me and my friend went there for dinner and it was amazing ”
“ We have been customers of Rosemarie's for years. Prior to the pandemic, we were there for dinner weekly. The last couple of years, we have been ordering their trays of food to go. I have had the pleasure of dealing with Gianna several times. She cannot do enough and always goes above and beyond, always making sure her customers are pleased. You will not be disappointed with Rosemarie's! ”
“ Tried the pizza and eggplant parmigiana from here, it was sooo good!!! The sauce is phenomenal, lots of flavor! Will try other dishes the next time. ”
“ Rolled in from out of town, AMAZING service and pizza on Long Island. HAVE to get Rosemarie’s grandma slice, the the garlicky sauce fresh mozzarella is unbeatable with the thicker crust. Sean was a delight and made sure we had a delicious and great experience. Even threw in extra snacks on the house, best pizza place in Farmingdale! ”
“ Rosemarie's Pizzeria is a fantastic spot to grab a delicious bite! The food is top-notch, with a great variety of pizzas that are always fresh, hot, and packed with flavor. John, the manager, really makes the experience stand out—he’s super friendly and welcoming, always making sure everything runs smoothly. Plus, his sweatpants were incredible, adding a whole new level of cool to the vibe of the place. If you’re in the area, you’ve got to check it out! Oh, and by the way, I’m a cat—meowwww! ”
“ I can’t say enough good things about this place! The pizza is absolutely incredible—perfectly crispy crust, rich sauce, and the right amount of cheese. The chicken rolls are stuffed generously and baked to perfection, making them a must-try. The zeppoles are fluffy, sweet, and melt in your mouth! Highly recommend if you’re craving some seriously delicious comfort food! ”
“ Ms. Geiana, and Mr. Manni, are some of the kindest most amazing people. Their food is always perfect as is their service. After my wife relocated to live with me in my home state of M.S, I have eaten pizza throughout different states and nothing compares to Rosemarie's. Their dinner menu (non pizza options) are amazing as well!.. Rosemarie's is always one of our first stops. I eat there multiple times a week during my stay. I would drive hours just to go there if I could. Thank you both for everything y'all treated us like family. Sincerely, John/Johnny ”
“ Food is excellent service was excellent waitress The Amazing Grace was good very accommodating and fun ”
Menu
Chicken Francese Hero
US$14.25Side Sausage
US$8.00Caesar Wrap
US$13.00Buffalo Wrap
US$13.00Balsamic Wrap
US$13.00
About
Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Welcome to Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant, a hidden gem nestled at 188 Merritts Rd in Farmingdale, NY. If you're on the hunt for authentic Italian cuisine with a local twist, look no further. This beloved spot is not just a pizzeria; it's a culinary experience that captures the heart of both tradition and flavor.
One of the standout features here is the extensive menu that promises something for every palate. From mouthwatering heroes like the Chicken Francese Hero and the delicious Meatball Hero, each dish is crafted with care and attention to detail. The Chicken and Peppers Hero topped with fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers is a highlight, showcasing a delightful mix of textures and tastes that make each bite a celebration of flavors.
But the excitement doesn't stop there. Their selection of appetizers, including the Baci Meatballs served with ricotta and Fried Calamari, sets the stage for a truly remarkable meal. The sweet chili calamari, with its perfect crunch and zesty dip, could easily become your new favorite starter. For those who crave the comfort of baked pasta, indulge in the Meat Lasagna or the Baked Stuffed Shells—items that bring warmth and nostalgia to the table.
Customer feedback speaks volumes about Rosemarie's dedication to quality and service. Loyal patrons like Linda Humbert praise the exceptional care and attention they receive, noting staff members like Gianna who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant experience. New visitors, such as Robert Sedlak and Hannah Christianson, rave about the impeccable service and delectable pizza, specifically highlighting the renowned grandma slice which boasts a thicker crust paired with a garlicky sauce and fresh mozzarella that leaves a lasting impression.
For those passionate about flavorful, no-frills dining, Rosemarie's shines brightly. As Billy Joel humorously mentions, the experience is elevated by the friendly ambiance cultivated by staff like John, who is known for being welcoming and making sure every guest feels at home. It's this community spirit, combined with an array of delicious offerings, that truly makes Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant a must-visit.
In a world where dining out often feels hurried, Rosemarie's stands as a beacon of warmth, where you can savor incredible flavors and create lasting memories. So, whether you're a local or just passing through, be sure to stop by for a slice—or two. Your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table